The Dual Mandate of Functional Rhinoplasty
Definitions and scope: what’s cosmetic vs. what’s functional?
- Cosmetic rhinoplasty focuses on contour, symmetry, and proportion—without a medical indication.
- Functional rhinoplasty treats structural causes of obstruction (think valve collapse, septal deviation, turbinate hypertrophy) and can also include aesthetic refinements.
- In practice, these goals are often combined (septorhinoplasty) because structure shapes airflow—especially across the midvault and nasal tip where form and function are tightly linked.
Nasal airflow 101 and the internal/external valve complex
The nose isn’t just a tube. It humidifies, warms, filters, and directs airflow. Most resistance comes from the “valves”:
- The internal nasal valve (INV) is the narrowest segment—where the septum meets the upper lateral cartilage (ULC) near the head of the inferior turbinate—usually forming a 10–15° angle. Tiny shape changes here can dramatically alter resistance.
- The external nasal valve (ENV) is the nostril opening framed by the alar rim, columella, and nasal sill. Weak alar cartilage or poor lateral wall support invites inspiratory collapse (hello, Bernoulli forces).
- Either valve can narrow at rest or buckle under negative pressure. That’s why someone can have a straight septum and a “normal” CT—and still breathe poorly.
Evidence and what patients actually feel: NOSE and SCHNOS
Objective airflow tests help, but breathing is ultimately about lived experience. Two validated tools anchor quality:
- NOSE (Nasal Obstruction Symptom Evaluation): a 5‑item, 0–100 scale for obstruction severity. Functional rhinoplasty often produces large improvements (commonly 30–50 points), depending on baseline and anatomy.
- SCHNOS (Standardized Cosmesis and Health Nasal Outcomes Survey): measures both obstruction (“O”) and cosmesis (“C”), letting you link breathing improvement to aesthetic satisfaction.
How looks and airflow intertwine: dorsum, midvault, and tip support
Aesthetics and mechanics are inseparable. Changes meant to beautify can backfire on breathing:
- Reducing a dorsal hump without rebuilding the midvault risks an inverted‑V deformity and a tighter INV.
- Over‑resecting the lateral crura can destabilize the alar rim—leading to ENV collapse.
- De‑rotating or under‑projecting the tip can shorten the columella–alar relationship and shrink valve geometry.
Preoperative Assessment and Integrated Planning
History and exam: mucosa, allergy, OSA, meds, habits
- Ask about seasonal symptoms, sinus infections, CPAP use, nasal trauma, prior surgeries.
- Review anticoagulants, intranasal drug use, smoking/vaping, and autoimmune issues.
- Screen for OSA: nasal surgery rarely cures OSA but can improve CPAP tolerance and lower required pressures.
Imaging and metrics: what CT shows—and what it doesn’t
- CT helps map bony deviations, concha bullosa, or sinus disease. Correlation with symptoms isn’t perfect—CT doesn’t measure airflow.
- Consider rhinomanometry, PNIF, and acoustic rhinometry to complement endoscopy and set a baseline.
Aesthetic analysis, digital simulation, and expectation alignment
- Analyze frontal, lateral, oblique, and base views: radix, dorsal lines, tip projection/rotation, alar–columellar relationships.
- Digital morphing can preview realistic changes—especially when widening the valve or placing grafts may subtly alter contours.
- Be upfront about trade‑offs: sometimes a small aesthetic compromise secures durable airflow (and sometimes the reverse).
Documenting medical necessity and navigating payers
- Capture:
- Duration/severity (NOSE/SCHNOS scores).
- Physical findings (photos of dynamic collapse, endoscopy).
- Failed conservative therapy (e.g., 6–12 weeks of intranasal steroids/saline).
- Objective airflow data, when available.
- Separate medically necessary work (valve repair, septoplasty, turbinate reduction) from purely cosmetic refinements—typically self‑pay.
Operative Strategies that Unite Form and Function
Septoplasty plus structure: spreader, batten, lateral crural strut, and extracorporeal options
- Septoplasty recenters the L‑strut while preserving dorsal/caudal support. Scoring or swinging maneuvers help correct high deviations.
- Spreader grafts (septal or auricular cartilage) rebuild the midvault, widen the INV, and prevent inverted‑V deformity after dorsal reduction.
- Septal batten grafts help with stubborn caudal or high septal warps.
- Extracorporeal septoplasty tackles severe deformity—remove, straighten, and reconstruct the septum before reimplanting a stable, straight L‑strut.
Stabilizing the nasal valves: sutures, batten support, implants
- Flaring sutures between ULC and dorsal septum widen the INV without extra bulk—great for mild narrowing.
- Alar batten grafts reinforce the lateral crura/alar rim to stop ENV collapse (precise pocketing prevents visible edges).
- Lateral crural strut grafts reposition and stiffen weak or cephalically malpositioned LLCs.
- Lateral wall implants (e.g., absorbable polylactide) can stiffen a collapsible lateral wall via a minimally invasive route—useful in select dynamic collapse or revisions.
- For complex midvault narrowing, a butterfly graft (conchal cartilage) can widen the INV and smooth dorsal contour at the same time.
Turbinate management (mucosa matters): submucosal reduction, radiofrequency, outfracture
- Submucosal resection (cold steel or microdebrider) reduces bulk while preserving mucosa.
- Radiofrequency ablation shrinks tissue with low morbidity and minimal crusting.
- Outfracture repositions the turbinate bone laterally to expand space.
- Avoid aggressive partial/total turbinectomy—dryness, crusting, and empty‑nose syndrome are real risks.
Access and materials: open vs. endonasal; septal, auricular, costal cartilage
- Open approach: best for complex grafting, severe deviation, revision cases, or tip/alar reconstruction—maximum exposure, predictable control.
- Endonasal approach: fits isolated septoplasty, limited valve grafts, or modest dorsal work—less soft‑tissue edema.
- Grafts:
- Septal cartilage: first choice—straight, strong, easy to harvest.
- Auricular (conchal) cartilage: curved and springy—ideal for alar batten or butterfly grafts.
- Costal cartilage: abundant for major reconstruction; mitigate warping with balanced carving, cross‑lamination, or diced cartilage in fascia when appropriate.
From Our Blog
Ethnic Rhinoplasty: Respecting Heritage and Identity Through Tailored Surgical Technique
Elective facial surgery is powerful. It can boost confidence, restore function, and reshape how someone is viewed—and how they view themselves. That’s especially true with rhinoplasty. “Ethnic rhinoplasty” isn’t a separate operation;
READ THE ARTICLE
Non-Surgical Alternatives vs. Surgical Rhinoplasty: What You Need to Know About Liquid Rhinoplasty (Filler) Versus Surgery
Elective changes to the nose sit right where aesthetics meets function. Some people want to smooth a small hump without taking time off work; others need true structural change and better airflow. Today, you’ve basically got two very different routes.
READ THE ARTICLE
Open vs. Closed Rhinoplasty: Which Technique Is Right for You? Differences, Pros, and Cons
Rhinoplasty isn’t one single operation—it’s a toolkit of techniques that reshape the nasal framework to improve how your nose looks, works, or both. The two main approaches—open (external) and closed (endonasal)—are simply different ways to reach the same anatomy.
READ THE ARTICLE
Which Type of Nose Surgery Is Best for You?
Your nose plays a big role in how your face looks and how you breathe. For some people, it’s about refining appearance. For others, it’s about improving airflow or correcting past surgeries. No matter the reason, the goal is the same: to create a natural, balanced result that fits your face and function.
READ THE ARTICLE